Golden Oat Crème Pie (Stuff’d)

Molasses + Vanilla

Thick, chewy brown butter oatmeal cookies layered with warm cinnamon, toasted oat crumble, and deep molasses richness, sandwiched around a silky brown sugar “cream cheese” buttercream with notes of vanilla and caramelized sugar.

Soft-centered with lightly crisp edges and packed with nostalgic bakery flavor, this oversized golden oatmeal crème pie is rich, comforting, and unapologetically indulgent… the perfect balance of cozy spice and smooth buttery sweetness.

Always in Good Measure.

Sweetness Measure: *** (3/5)

***********************************
**All items are baked fresh to order. Please allow 3 days for processing before shipment. Read more on weekly cutoffs/shipping schedule below**

***********************************

One cookie sandwich per pack | Weight: 4.5oz

*Small-batch crafted. Toppings and decorative details may vary, but the flavor profile remains intentionally consistent — Always in Good Measure.

*Custom orders may be modified to add or remove fillings/toppings.

Ingredients: Cookies: Flour, Oats, Butter, Sugar, Eggs, Molasses, Vanilla, Cinnamon, Milk powder, Cornstarch, Baking Soda, Butter Emulsion, Cream Cheese Emulsion, Salt. Filling: Sugar, Butter, Marshmallow, Vanilla, Corn Syrup, Cream Cheese Powder, Butter Emulsion, Cream Cheese Emulsion, Salt.

Allergens: Wheat, Eggs, Milk

All cookies are made in an environment that handles most food allergens. Although precautions have been taken, we cannot guarantee there hasn’t been cross contamination.

**Weekly Cutoff/Shipping/Pick Up Schedule: 

Orders placed by Tuesday, 12pm (EST) will be shipped no later than Thursday and delivered no later than Saturday each week. Orders placed after the Tuesday cutoff will be processed and shipped on the following Thursday (next week).

Orders placed by Thursday, 12pm (EST) are available for local pickup every Saturday between 11am-12pm (EST) in Aberdeen, MD (or surrounding HarCo area).

***********************************